MailmanWiki

Google Summer of Code 2022 Ideas Page

Take me straight to the ideas!

Mailman is free software for managing electronic mail discussion and e-newsletter lists. Mailman is integrated with the web, making it easy for users to manage their accounts and for list owners to administer their lists. Mailman supports built-in archiving, automatic bounce processing, content filtering, digest delivery, spam filters, and more. Many open source denizens will be familiar with Mailman 2.1, which is used to manage many project mailing lists. All of our current work is on Mailman 3, which was released in 2015, but there's still lots of room for new features and ideas!

Not sure about how GSoC works? Check out the resources at Summer of Code Home

Contents

  1. Google Summer of Code 2022 Ideas Page
    1. Getting Started
    2. Recommended Skills
    3. What is Mailman Suite?
    4. Documentation & Installation
    5. GSoC Application Process
    6. Contacting us
    7. Writing Your Application
    8. FAQ
  2. Project Ideas
    1. List Configuration Tool
      1. Requirements
      2. Mentors
    2. User Profile Tool
      1. Requirements
      2. Mentors
    3. Moderating Emails and Threads in Hyperkitty
      1. Requirements
      2. Mentors
    4. Support for REST Callbacks in Core
      1. Requirements
      2. Mentors
    5. Support for Encrypted Lists
      1. Requirements
      2. Mentors
    6. Improved UI for Subscription Management
      1. Requirements
      2. Mentors
    7. Systemwide User Defaults
      1. Requirements
      2. Mentors
    8. Dynamic Sublists (aka Conversations)
      1. Requirements
      2. Mentors
    9. HTML Digests
      1. Requirements
      2. Mentors
    10. Configurable Mail Footers
      1. Requirements
      2. Mentors
    11. 'Site' Wide List Configurations
      1. Requirements
      2. Mentors
    12. The Generic Project Template
      1. Requirements
      2. Mentors

Getting Started

The GSoC student Guide has some great general GSoC information. Read it first!

Before you ask any questions about how to do anything in git or initialize your repository please read through the git howto and see if that answers your questions.

Here's a few skills that will make it easier for you to get started as a Mailman developer:

Specific projects may have additional desired skills listed along with them.

What is Mailman Suite?

In Mailman 3, we've divided up the code into a number of sub-projects. We refer to the whole package as "Mailman Suite" and there's a few really important pieces you should know:

There's also a number of smaller projects that provide the glue to make these pieces work well together, or allow them to be used separately.

All the Mailman 3 source is on GitLab.

Documentation & Installation

Here are some useful links to get you started with Mailman Development:

Mailman is written in Python. Mailman supports Python 3.5+. Each individual projects may have their own restrictions on the Python versions you can use depending on the support of the their dependencies.

Development work on Mailman 2.1 has been frozen for some time, so all new project ideas must be related to Mailman 3.

GSoC Application Process

To be considered as an applicant for Google Summer of Code 2021, we need you to contribute at least one non-trivial Merge Request and have that accepted.

The best way to get started is to set up a local development environment, documentation for which is available here.

You can then find issues tagged with "beginner-friendly" and "easy" on our Gitlab Page. Or ask us on the mailing lists (but showing you've checked the GitLab issues first is something we consider anencouraging sign!) Feel free to open more issues when you find them.

Contacting us

The most successful GSoC students are the ones who work closely with the Mailman team. As you might expect from a group that makes mailing list software, our preferred method of communication is our mailing list, but we also have an IRC channel. Please do not send private messages or emails unless asked to do so or the subject is personal rather than technical, since we get a lot of similar questions and would rather the questions and answers happen in public so everyone can benefit.

Writing Your Application

FAQ

This page might be of some help.

This question has been asked tons of times on the mailing list (mentioned above) and IRC Channel (again, mentioned above). Both of them are logged publicly and are searchable. It would be really nice to go through them once before you ask the same question again. More specific questions are encouraged and receive more attention than "How do I start?". Mentors do try hard to reply to each and every email to the developers list, but in case you don't get any replies on trivial questions, don't be discouraged. Also, in case you are a student, helping others with small problems that you know about is also a great way to get noticed. Don't worry too much about giving wrong answers, list is constantly monitored by the core developers and your mistakes would be corrected.

Issues, bugs and tests are obviously a good way to contribute. But, writing/improving documentation is another great way to contribute for beginners. It doesn't have to be a real commit or patch, write up a detailed blog post about what problems you faced while setting up mailman for development. What parts of mailman you find are difficult to understand? What are awesome things about mailman?

Note: To qualify for Google Summer of Code, your proposed project must be a coding project. That's Google's rule. Documentation and tests help to make a substantial contribution, but only count toward GSoC to the extent that they apply to your new or changed code. Additional work on documentation or testing is considered a community contribution, which is a consideration in deciding who to accept.

In most of the cases the reason for a MR to be pending is that there is either something missing or something incorrect. In either of those cases, first check the MR itself and any issues associated with it, to see if there are comment you have missed. If it's not obvious what you need to do next, contact any mentor or the org admin (Steve = yaseppochi@IRC) and we'll look into it, or ask the relevant person. I don't mean that you do that for each one, just the ones that haven't been noticed by anyone for a long time. (Use your judgment as to what is "long" when there's a deadline coming up.)

Project Ideas

This is the list of project ideas. Do communicate with the developers before writing a proposal based on any of these ideas. The developers work individually on issues that catch their eye either as a feature they want, or at a user's request. So somebody may already be working on an idea, and you may be wasting your time to propose it.

If you have an idea not listed here that you'd like to propose , please send it to mailman-developers@python.org for discussion! You can also look at the to-do lists for Mailman 3 here, and see if anything is interesting enough that you would like to work on it through the summer.

If you saw an idea on an earlier year's page and thought it would be a good project, but it isn't here, most likely it has been implemented and is in the current distribution. Sorry!

List Configuration Tool

Postorius allows list administrators to configure their lists conveniently, but at present it's difficult to export list configuration settings to another server, or create a template for new lists based on an existing list. For example, here's a short thread on such a problem.

The object of this task is to create a tool which allows a list administrator to work with a list's configuration (by default not including the membership roster) as a whole, to export it to a list template on the same server, or as a text file (probably JSON, but XML, .ini, YAML, etc might be considered) that can be used to migrate a list to a different server.

Requirements

Mentors

User Profile Tool

Mailman 3 allows users to set some profile information at several scopes: user-wide, per-address, or per-subscription. While "power users" enjoy the flexibility, others find it inconvenient and confusing that settings at subscription scope don't propagate to the address or user scopes. This is especially annoying when they ask a list administrator to help them, because the list administrator normally doesn't have access to the user profile object, although they do have access to their list roster (including user preferences). For example, here's a short thread on such a problem.

The object of this task is to create and integrate into Postorius a tool which allows the user to easily modify their preferences in any scope, and which helps them to propagate changes where appropriate, and not do so when not. It should probably present initially at user scope, even if invoked from subscription level. It should offer the ability to show a "map" of the scopes in which preferences are set to non-default values. List administrators should be warned about the limitations on their own access. A possible feature (but I haven't thought about it carefully, and don't know if users would want it) would be to send a one-time key to the list admin allowing them to access the user's profile as the user. (This needs careful thought -- should the admin be able to change credentials? other lists' preferences?)

Requirements

Mentors

Moderating Emails and Threads in Hyperkitty

Hyperkitty is GNU Mailman's official archiver. However, it also supports some advanced functionality which allows users to send messages/emails through its web interface.

Moderation of topics being discussed in a Mailing List has been one of the biggest complaints on Mailman Users. Email is a very distributed and open protocol, which makes it hard to restrict users from following up on threads that have been going on for a long time and need to be shut down.

With Hyperkitty, we can tackle this problem by adding moderation actions to specific Email Headers. This allows us to moderate all the replies to a message (In-Reply-To: and References: header fields).

Requirements

Mentors

Support for REST Callbacks in Core

Mailman Core exposes a REST API for the clients to request information from it and display that to users in their respective UI. Postorius uses the API to allow admins/list owners to manage the lists and subscribers to manage their subscription. Hyperkitty uses the API to fetch information about the new mailing lists created so that it is ready to archive emails for those lists.

The changes in the Core's database today aren't conveyed to Clients. Instead, clients which care about changes must poll the REST API , which is quite inefficient.

Core could use a pub-sub model to send out events, which Hyperkitty and Postorius (clients) can subscribe to.

Tags: core

Requirements

Mentors

Support for Encrypted Lists

This is an idea that has been around for a while and there are a number of custom implementations in the wild, we hear. The problem as usual is key distribution and management. The obvious distributed implementation using PGP requires everyone on the list to know everyone else's public key, and to encrypt using all of them. The basic idea is to add each subscriber's public key to their profile, so that subscribers only need to know the list's public key. Then the list would do the reencryption. That way subscribers only need to manage two keys: their own and the list's. The devil is in the details. For example, the list is by definition a person in the middle. To what extent can Mailman help to improve site security? A naive implementation would put plaintext on disk. Can that be avoided? What about archives? Some of these questions are design questions, and (for the purpose of GSoC) it doesn't matter how you answer them. But they do need to be answered and documented.

The simplest, *low functionality*, model would involve disabling archives, and poster to server and server to subscriber encryption.

A *high functionality* model would offer archives, with some degree of forward security as well as security in transit.

Tags: core (securing the core), postorius (configuring an encrypted list), hyperkitty (archive management)

Requirements

Mentors

Improved UI for Subscription Management

This is a collection of small improvements. For example, Postorius currently presents minimal information on the subscriber list page, with a link to each subscription's options page. There should at least be an option to view the most important options as a table, and a link to the subscriber's profile only for verbose or rarely used fields. At present, the list of lists view does not present "private" lists to the logged user, even if they are a subscriber. There should be a option between public and private making lists visible to subscribers but not nonsubscribers.

Tags: postorius

Requirements

Mentors

Systemwide User Defaults

In Mailman 2, it was possible to set defaults for options for new subscriptions to a list. In Mailman 3, some site admins would like to do this systemwide, but it currently requires patching the Python code. There should be a UI in Postorius to do this at all administrative levels (list, domain, site).

Tags: core postorius (pick one representing your focus: database schema and access, or administrator UI)

Requirements

Mentors

Dynamic Sublists (aka Conversations)

Dynamic sublists are a feature of the Systers fork of Mailman which was never integrated upstream due to entanglement with other, very Systers-specific, features of their fork. The idea is that only the thread root is distributed to all users, and by replying to a special address, a reader can "subscribe" to that thread. Because of divergence of the code bases integration will likely involve some amount of new code. Also, the original feature was controlled entirely by email, but integration with Postorius and HyperKitty is desirable.

Tags: core

Requirements

Mentors

HTML Digests

Thanks to Jay Hamilton-Roth for the suggestion.

Background: For the non-technical users of MM3, the Mime digest format is only useful on a small subset of email readers (e.g., Outlook and iPad/iPhone Email). The majority of "average" users cannot easily parse nor reply to messages in the digest, making the digest not very useful.

The current digest format is:

1. The masthead from the list:member:digest:masthead template. 2. The digest header if any from the list:member:digest:header template. 3. The table of contents. 4. The individual messages. 5. The digest footer from the list:member:digest:footer template.

For the MIME digest, these are all separate MIME parts and the individual messages are message/rfc822 parts within a multipart/digest part.

For the plain text digest, the digest is one text/plain part containing the above formatted par RFC 1153

Goal: A simple HTML customizable digest format could help to make digests more usable.

Suggestion: Create new html template files (that could live in list:member:htmldigest): masthead, header, footer, tocheader, tocfooter, msgheader, msgfooter. These would allow for customized ornamentation. The masthead would also include the following digest classes by default: .digest_msg_start, .digest_msg_number, .digest_msg_reply, .digest_msg_reply_all, .digest_msg_archive, and .digest_msg_end. List owners could configure any of these classes to set the visibility property to hidden.

This would create a proposed HTML digest format as:

1. The masthead from the list:member:htmldigest:masthead template.

2. The digest header if any from the list:member:htmldigest:header template.

3. The toc header if any from the list:member:htmldigest:tocheader template

4. The table of contents.

5. The toc footer if any from the list:member:htmldigest:tocheader template

6. Foreach message

  1. The msg header if any from the list:member:htmldigest:msgheader template followed by 

   <div class="digest_msg_number">message number</div>
   <div class="digest_msg_title">message subject</div>

   <div class="digest_msg_reply"><a href="mailto:SenderURL?subject=message subject">Reply to sender</a> </div>
   <div class="digest_msg_reply_all"><a href="mailto:ListURL?subject=message subject">Reply to group</a> </div>
   <div class="digest_msg_archive"><a href="archiveURL">Thread</a></div>

7. The digest footer from the list:member:htmldigest:footer template.

For example, the default for htmldigest:msgheader could be <hr>

An HTML digest is probably only greatly useful if you're going to prohibit HTML mail or convert it to plain text in digests. The HTML produced by commercial MUAs is complex, and it's hard to predict how it will interact with the digest formatting.

If HTML mail will be allowed, we would need to examples of what at least the most common mail composers on your lists are going to throw at us. (Somebody else can do the followup work for composers you've never seen. ;-) The problem is that we may have to "unwrap" the HTML document and parse the HEAD element to integrate them into a digest correctly and provide a convenient UI.

Tag: core

Requirements

Mentors

Configurable Mail Footers

While generally a good idea to have the existing mail footers on mailing list, there exist some mailing lists where having the footers is basically a non-starter. This can currently be achieved by editing the templates directly, but this is obvious cumbersome. This project is intended to focus on piping through postorious the UI elements needed to configure those footers on a per-list, or per-site basis. (basically give an editor in postorious for the respective var/templates/domains/<domain>/<lang>/ files)

Requirements

Mentors

'Site' Wide List Configurations

Currently settings are applied to each individual list, and there's not a 'good' way to make lists conform on an entire site level. Example scenario: you know that all sites need to have a specific setting, when you create a new list you want that setting to be already applied. There's obviously a couple of different ways to go about this, and work has been done in this direction in previous GSoCs however it has yet to be fully completed. This is intended to further the work, with the intention of getting this added directly in.

Requirements

Mentors

The Generic Project Template

We're open to original proposals from candidates. Trawl the mailman-users@mailman3.org and Mailman developers mailing list mailing list archives and the GitLab issue trackers for user feature requests and proposals. Be careful and consult with us before doing much work on a proposal, though: Google requires a certain minimum amount of work (approximately full-time for 10 weeks) and that the work produce code (not tests, UI styling, or documentation).

Tag: as appropriate

Requirements

Mentors

MailmanWiki: DEV/Google Summer of Code 2022 (last edited 2022-04-18 14:21:00 by stephen@xemacs.org)